Accuracy of “Professional” FX Forecasters
“There are two kinds of investors, be they large or small: Those who don’t know where the market is headed, and those who don’t know that they don’t know. Then again, there is a third type of investor: The investment professional, who indeed knows that he or she doesn’t know, but whose livelihood depends upon appearing to know.”
– William Bernstein
The above quote likely resonates with those who have followed any financial market for long enough, and the foreign exchange market is certainly not an exception. Nevertheless, those tasked with managing FX risk are often asked either where they think various FX rates are headed, or more commonly, to find out where “the pros” think they are headed. Far too often, someone in Corporate Treasury is asked to poll their relationship bankers in an attempt to determine the consensus FX rate forecasts, and then incorporate these directional views into the company’s hedging strategy. Surely these highly paid economic PhDs must know something more than the rest of us?
Professional v. Current Spot FX forecasting update
Analysis of consensus* FX forecasts as compared to a spot rate method ** of simply using the existing spot rate as the best estimate of future spot rate finds that the pros consistently do WORSE than the spot rate forecasting method.
Why is this? As William Bernstein has pointed out, professionals aren’t necessarily getting paid to be accurate, and are often incented to make a bold prediction with the hope that it will come to pass. Nobody gives much credit to a boring but accurate forecast that may be similar to today’s environment, but a shocking prediction will probably generate more discussions or clicks, and potentially a future high-profile interview if it turns out to be accurate. Worse yet, when a certain directional view becomes widely held by the forecasters (and therefore most likely to show up in a consensus forecast), this is often reflective of investments already being made in that direction, with little fuel left in the market to add to the trend. In absence of new money to help move in the forecasted direction, the markets often turn the other way, making these consensus forecasts contrarian indicators more often than accurate forecasts.
* Bloomberg Consensus
** Using the spot rate on Dec 31 as the forecast for the following four quarter EUR
*** The Current Spot vs. Professional forecast for the JPY and EUR against the USD was accurate for 7 out of 11 years.
EUR Current Spot 5.2% delta vs. Professional 6.3% delta
JPY Current Spot 6.2% delta vs. Professional 7.3% delta